Tile sheds water. Underlayment stops it.
A tile roof is a two-part system. The tile on top is a water-shedding layer: it protects the roof from sun and impact and carries most rain down to the gutter. But tile is not watertight. Wind-driven rain gets under it, water wicks through laps and around fasteners, and the gaps at hips, ridges and valleys let moisture in. Everything that gets past the tile lands on the underlayment, which is the actual waterproofing layer.
On most Orange County homes built from the 1970s into the 1990s, that underlayment is asphalt-saturated organic felt, commonly 30-pound, sometimes in a single layer, nailed to the deck under wood battens or directly under the tile. It was the standard product of its time. It was never expected to last as long as the tile above it.
What 25 to 30 years does to felt underlayment
Concrete and clay tile can last 50 years or more. Felt typically does not get close to that in Southern California. Several things wear it out.
Heat is the first. On a sunny slope, the air space under tile gets very hot through the summer, and felt slowly loses the oils that keep it flexible. Over decades it becomes brittle, cracks along the battens and at bends, and tears when it moves. Inland roofs in places like Anaheim Hills, Irvine and Mission Viejo see more heat than coastal ones, but even coastal roofs get there eventually.
Nail holes are the second. Every tile and batten nail punctures the felt. When the felt is new, it seals tightly around the fastener. As it dries out, those holes open up, and each one becomes a path for water running down the slope.
The third is debris and trapped water. Leaves, dust and bird nesting material build up under tile at battens, eaves and valleys, damming water against the felt. Wood battens that stay wet rot, loosening the tile they hold. Metal valleys and flashings, often plain galvanized steel on older roofs, rust, especially near the coast.
None of this is visible from the ground. The tile stays the same color and shape. That is why so many homeowners are surprised to learn their 30-year-old roof needs major work.
Warning signs your underlayment is failing
Because water travels along the deck before it drips, underlayment leaks often appear far from where the water entered. These are the common clues on Orange County tile roofs.
- Leaks that only appear in long or wind-driven storms, not light rain
- Ceiling stains below valleys, skylights, chimneys or where a second story meets a lower roof
- Brittle, torn or crumbling felt visible at the eaves or under a lifted tile
- Soft or stained sheathing and fascia along the eaves
- Slipped or sagging rows of tile, which can point to rotted battens
- Rust stains or holes in valley metal and wall flashings
- A roof that is 25 or more years old and has never had the underlayment replaced
How a lift-and-relay works
A lift-and-relay, also called a tile reset or underlayment replacement, replaces everything under the tile while reusing the tile itself. On a typical Orange County home, the process looks like this.
The crew removes the tile and stacks it on the roof or on the ground, keeping track of trim pieces like ridges, hips and rakes. The old felt, battens and worn flashings are torn off down to the deck. Damaged or rotted sheathing is replaced, along with any rotted fascia. New underlayment goes on, typically in two layers or as a high-temperature synthetic or self-adhered product, depending on the slope and the manufacturer's system. New flashings are installed at valleys, walls, chimneys, skylights and pipes, along with new battens where the system uses them, eave closures, and bird stops. Then the original tile is reinstalled, fastened to current code, with broken pieces replaced by matching tile, and ridges and hips are reset.
The roof looks the same when it is done. What has changed is the part that keeps water out, which now has decades of life ahead of it instead of being at the end of it. A re-roof like this is typically permitted through the city, or through OC Public Works in unincorporated areas, and inspected like any other re-roof.
Upgrades worth making during a reset
Since the tile is already off, a reset is the cheapest time to fix details that caused problems the first time around.
- Corrosion-resistant valley and wall flashing near the coast, where salt air destroys plain galvanized steel
- Raised battens or counter-battens that let water drain and air circulate under the tile
- Properly flashed solar mounts if panels will be reinstalled
- Additional attic insulation or a radiant barrier, which can also help with Title 24 requirements in inland climate zones
- Updated ventilation at eaves and ridges to reduce heat on the new underlayment
- Ember- and pest-resistant eave closures, especially in fire hazard zones
When the tile has to be replaced instead
Reusing tile saves money and keeps the look, but it is not always possible. These are the situations where new tile, or a different roof covering, is the better answer.
Too much breakage. Older concrete tile can become more brittle and porous with age, and some breaks during removal no matter how carefully the work is done. When the expected breakage plus the pieces already cracked is high, the cost of matching replacements approaches the cost of new tile.
Discontinued profiles and colors. Many 1970s and 1980s tile profiles are no longer made. A small number of replacements can come from salvage or from hidden slopes. A large number usually cannot, and a patchwork of mismatched tile may not get HOA approval.
Failed early lightweight or fiber-cement products. Some lightweight and fiber-cement roofing products installed in the 1980s and 1990s have deteriorated badly over time, cracking, delaminating or crumbling. They generally cannot be reused and should be replaced.
Framing or weight concerns. If the framing has sagged or was never adequate for tile, a reset only puts the same load back on a weak structure. Reinforcement or a lighter roof covering may be needed.
A change in look. Owners who want a different color or profile, or whose HOA requires an update, will be buying new tile regardless. In inland Climate Zone 8, new tile on a re-roof of more than half the roof also has to meet Title 24's steep-slope reflectance rule or an equivalent such as R-38 attic insulation.
Cost, timing and what waiting does
A lift-and-relay is generally less expensive than installing new tile, because the largest material cost, the tile itself, is reused. It typically costs more than a simple repair, because the labor of removing and reinstalling every tile is significant. The exact figure depends on roof size, pitch, complexity, accessibility, breakage, decking condition and permit requirements.
The real cost difference shows up when owners wait. A reset done while the deck is still sound is a re-roof. A reset done after several wet winters can include replacing sheathing, fascia, rafter tails, insulation, drywall and interior finishes. Felt failure does not reverse, so the question is usually when the work happens, not whether.